November 5, 2025 at 9:05AM – Unofficial Results
Election 2025 in the Town of Huntington was an edge-of-your-seat night as the Candidates for many of the local positions exchanged the front runner spot at least once as the results were tallied. 26.49% of 163,595 registered voters cast their ballot for Town Supervisor. Half of the races were so close that News12 Long Island* hasn’t marked the finalists as winners yet. This story will be updated with official results.
Congratulations to all of the winners! We look forward to working with you in the future. Huntington Matters expresses deep appreciation for all of our Candidates who stepped forward to run for office, giving our community great choices at the polls.
Huntington Town Supervisor
Ed Smyth (Republican, Conservative – Incumbent): 21,368 votes = 49%
Cooper Macco (Democratic): 20,766 votes = 48%
Maria Delgado (Working Families): 1,195 votes = 3%
Huntington Town Council
Jen Hebert (Democratic): 22,396 votes = 26%
Dr. Dave Bennardo (Republican, Conservative – Incumbent): 21,169 votes = 25%
Stephen Anastasia (Democratic): 20,046 votes = 24%
Gregory Grizopoulos (Conservative, Republican): 19,032 votes = 22%
George Bergbuchler (Working Families): 1,153 votes = 1%
Erick Greene (Working Families): 848 votes = 1%
Huntington Superintendent of Highways
Andre Sorrentino (Republican, Conservative – Incumbent): 22,839 votes = 54% ~ WINNER*
Vincent E. Colavita (Democratic): 18,819 votes = 44%
Chris Haines (Working Families): 940 votes = 2%
Suffolk County Legislator – District 18
Stephanie Bontempi (Republican, Conservative – Incumbent): 11,442 votes = 51%
Craig Herskowitz (Democratic): 11,063 = 49%
Suffolk County Legislator – District 17
Thomas Donnelly (Democratic, Conservative – Incumbent): 6,758 votes = 70% ~ WINNER*
Kevin Judge (Republican): 2,963 votes = 30%
Suffolk County Legislator – District 16
Rebecca Sanin (Democratic, Working Families – Incumbent): 7,600 votes = 58% ~ WINNER*
Chad Lupinacci (Republican, Conservative): 5,397 votes = 42%
Suffolk County Legislator – District 15
Jason Richberg (Democratic – Incumbent): 6,861 votes = 73% ~ WINNER*
Jarod Morris (Republican, Conservative): 2,503 votes = 27%
Suffolk Proposition Two
Change Legislator Terms from 2 Year Terms to 4 Year Terms
YES: 128,766 votes = 57% ~ WINNER*
NO: 95,383 votes = 43%
